Last year, I forged an intentional devotion to live music.
This resulted in me spending a good number of weekends at dinky house-shows surrounded by kids with gaudy appearances, and also, purchasing tickets to just about any concert I deemed mildly interesting enough to justify the price of. I wish I had a number that I could give you. It is likely that most of my money in 2024 went to Ticketmaster and 12 oz iced lattes.
The purpose of this operation, I maintained, was “experience”—social, or otherwise—and “experience”, I did. Plenty of shows were by and large unpleasant, many forgettable, a few mesmerizing, most passable. Occasionally I’d meet somebody nice to talk to or dance alongside, sometimes I’d end up sticky with sweat and aching from blows to the eyebrow piercing, regrettably more than a few times, I would just stand around and twitch my body to a drumbeat in some random backyard before quietly slipping away after one unsubstantial set.
Outside of a few small shows, I’ve been relatively distant from live music as of late, which has allowed me to do some thinking on these concerts and where they stand in memory as individual experiences. I came up with the idea to rank them in an Instagram story post or TikTok slideshow, but that seemed stupid and unrewarding and I just knew that my eyes would probably glaze over after the first entry, so instead I’d rather write a series of increasingly longwinded, multi-paragraph explanations of whether or not I had fun.
Like plenty of other things in life—food and thoughts to name a few—I keep track of all the live music I’ve seen via the Notes app. I’ve got a humble document titled “Concerts” wherein I accrue the names of every artist I see, even the ones in backyards. For the purpose of being both consistent and relevant (well, to be truthful this is partially because maybe not everything is worthy of precise record-keeping) I’ll be excluding any of those “local” or smaller shows I attended; this includes the aforementioned “houses” in my area1, but also “raves”, or shows put on by my friends. Let’s just keep it normal.
Also—I’m not actually here to critique the quality of individual performance or how the acoustics came through in each venue; often this has nothing to do with it. My list is really only concerned with the so-called “experience” derived, the most visceral and lasting impressions of each event as memory. Basically: I am biased and there is no rubric.
#15: Justice
WaMu Theater, Oct. 9th 2024
The photo I so regrettably took…
Thank God that I got the Salt and Straw October limited flavors before this. And for free? Can I just say: thank you to that employee, whatever her name was, like Yvette or Evonn or something, the girl who gave me that free ice cream. Wow. Seriously.
I can actually feel myself physically fighting against writing about this show. Whatever, it’s like, ever heard of “less is more”? Every single song—and I don’t even know how one would determine when exactly a “song” was played during this set, as it was sort of just continuous EDM noise—was like the epic Avengers Endgame version of its original make; it was actually unbearable.
At the start of the set, the purportedly sleek stage design drew some excitement from concertgoers, myself included. Admittedly, I even cheered and took a photo when the giant cross design first appeared in white LEDs, looming over the stage and, for a brief moment, projecting the illusion that this concert would allude to some of that dark, rebellious grime that Justice’s singular iconic album so decisively put forth. Never again. I’ll never let myself be tricked like that again. Already within the first few “songs” (?), the once impressive lights expended their charm completely, having fully transformed into a painful and overbearing distraction, an utter mess of lasers and strobes; less than 30 minutes in, I felt that my senses had been thoroughly assaulted. I was left exhausted, and not from exhilaration, but from demoralization. This is probably what it felt like to be a part of MKUltra.
For a duo who’s most popular song is literally called D.A.N.C.E., Justice sure made it impossible to do such. Their iconic melodies and tracks, more depressingly their sensibilities as a whole, were completely buried under the sheer amount of overstimulation. As a result, there was no center of gravity present within the crowd, no circle of dancing or movement to be pulled into, save for a few pockets that would inevitably burn out due to the excessive and directionless manner in which the songs were mutated. There was little stamina, and this wasn’t just because the demographic was primarily comprised of aging Millennials, it was because Justice chose to fry us with flashing lights and beat drops instead of just utilizing the elements within the songs that made them initially fun and exciting over a decade ago.
Before you get on me for expecting too much of artists who are past their “prime”, I absolutely did not go into this concert expecting some 1:1 reenactment of an “Indie Sleaze Party in a Basement Where Justice is Performing and Freaking Cobra Snake Shows Up and Takes Iconic Photos of Everybody Yo!!!!!”—I knew I was going to a big venue, I knew they were older, I am also quite aware that you cannot recreate the past. But man, I really thought I was at least going to, I don’t know, hear a Justice song.
I “danced”, I guess, but I feel totally disingenuous and embarrassed for having done such. I actually cannot emphasize enough how much better it would’ve been to just listen to a couple songs off Cross (2007) in the car rather than attend this show.
#14: Show Me the Body
Showbox, Oct. 8th 2024
Attending this was a last minute decision, one largely driven by the fact that tickets were only $15 if you went through a weird semi-hidden link on Instagram. I had actually seen Show Me the Body once before—almost exactly a year prior to this, same venue and all—when they toured alongside The Garden, and in my memory, they stood out as a highlight. During their set, I recall being unable to move whatsoever as the crowd’s intensity achieved total singularity, which is an underrated physical sensation. So sure, yeah, I’ll go see those guys again for 15 bucks!
Unfortunately, this was probably the most awkward concert I have ever been to (and I have a pretty high tolerance for second-hand embarrassment).
For starters, this was a five set show for which there was no reentry. With my next statement, I’ll likely leave some readers with a sneaking suspicion that perhaps I don’t actually like live music, but—5 sets is a slog. 5 sets at a “hardcore” show is nothing short of agonizing. And listen, I think most people (even those who claim to enjoy this sort of music) would actually agree with this sentiment if they allowed themselves to admit it, because you can find evidence of this at shows everywhere: folded arms and nodding heads, half-hearted head-banging, a “pit” that’s more of a pitiful nuisance than an inescapable vortex, the sneaky check of the time on phone lock screens.
It would be over two hours until Show Me the Body was on, and already by the first band I was put into a damned state. Quickly, I was reaffirmed in my belief that the worst thing about hardcore is somehow not even the uninspired, chugging sound of the music itself, but actually everything else about it. I felt myself physically recoiling at some of the sentiments shouted out by the bands—nonspecific references to “the scene” as though it were simultaneously an endangered species that required protection from invaders and also a tangible collective of individuals who furthered some cause for world peace; superficial calls to action (“Everybody better go fucking crazy!”) that would go largely ignored; skin-deep political organizing. The ubiquity of these forced, overt audience-artist interactions at hardcore or punk shows can be mostly attributed to the fact that the music is simply not nearly as motivating or invigorating as the surrounding mythos would like you to believe it is, which means its performers have to literally spell out what they think a “hardcore show” is supposed to look and feel like. The outcome can only be described as a disembodying level of embarrassment.
Okay guys, now is when you’re supposed to start like, punching each other and stuff for Palestine.
Even Show Me the Body couldn’t save us. The pit remained mostly a gaping hole, an oval shaped outline made up of what was primarily everybody in the audience avoiding this one kid in a COVID mask and overalls who was spinning around like an idiot. You cannot make this stuff up.
Some of it was alright—this was far from Justice levels of unlistenable festival parody music. My interest was piqued by the act “Special Interest” because their music seemed relatively out of place among the lineup, and overall, I thought punk outfit High Vis had the strongest and most genuine character of the night. Show Me the Body was fine, I guess; I liked that they played “K-9” this time.
I was upfront for the majority of this concert. It was unnervingly roomy, I swear everybody wanted to sheepishly gesture toward the barrier all like “No, you go ahead”. Even the apparent super-fan beside me, evidently the only one in attendance, appeared to fade away about halfway through the main show.
#13: Sanguisugabogg
El Corazon, Apr. 28th 2024
My brother had an extra ticket to this concert—actually, I think he really just needed a ride, but I accepted both proposals with little issue.
“Metal music” is sort of his “thing”. Metal, in its many forms, is pervasive within my family unit, a constant throughout my life. When my dad would pick me up after a long day of 4th grade, his car would be tuned to SiriusXM “Octane” Radio, which led my brain to develop a robust catalogue of Slipknot and Disturbed lyrics that I have yet to replace with useful knowledge; today if I end up in his car, there still remains a 90% chance that I will hear something the likes of Metallica or Death or a band that my brother showed him. Even now, at this precise moment, I am typing this to the muffled audio of said brother shouting along to a Megadeath song from the home gym.
It’s inevitable that I would have grown used to the genre as diegetic sound. Though speaking honestly, I never developed any real affection outside of nostalgia. I consider myself familiar and tolerant, but not necessarily friendly, with its guttural nature. This informs what I would like to call my “ethnographic approach” to metal shows: “I’m just passing by, don’t mind me, just scoping the place out.”
While starting to write this, I’m realizing I don’t remember this concert all that well. That should sum up its placement enough. Here’s my attempt at a recollection:
We arrived late at El Corazon—which many a Seattle resident could probably identify as the “establishment next door to the big scary clown sign that stares at the freeway by the 165 Exits”—and stood behind what might have been a few hyper-realistic statues of audience members during the tail-end of opening act Jesus Piece. Oh hey, they finally moved.
Sanguisugabogg is not a band I know anything about (I definitely don’t know how to spell their name), so when they finally came out I just kind of rode with it. The vocalist was this stocky man with a surprising charm and natural capability to rouse the crowd, which was almost exclusively middle aged genre-heads and guys who look like they’d be very into things like War Hammer or physical activities that are specifically associated with viking fandom and/or Renaissance fair culture, ie. archery or axe-throwing. Metal shows retain this advantage over hardcore or punk shows, that being the cultivation of a tangible community of sorts; this means the audience is far more likely to actually respond to stimulus such as, “This Next Song is About Ripping Your Fucking Guts Out!!!!” with some level of energy.
There was certainly no awkward roominess here; people kept stage-diving by me—one guy eventually plummeted directly onto my head, breaking the glasses I had just gotten repaired at Costco that week. In the grand scheme of things this is fine, they didn’t really look that good on me anyway.
Oh yeah, at one point the vocalist threw a foam football or something into the crowd, inciting a game called either “Murder Ball” or “Death Ball”, I don’t remember, which went on for two rounds before an old man, wild-eyed and thoroughly greased with sweat, emerged the victor.
I spent most of this concert in spectator mode, but was honestly fine doing such.
#12: Panchiko
Showbox, Apr. 21st 2024
An acknowledgement must be made—I give this show full credit for the origination of this review idea, because I walked away feeling decidedly negative and eager to share it.
Initially, I expected for this one to be at the start of the list. Panchiko is not a band that I fuck with: I don’t believe their lost-media-liminal-2000s-Japan-nostalgia schtick to be anything more than Gen-Z bait, a watered-down and truly impersonal interpretation of a broader aesthetic movement. I don’t even believe their cute little 4chan story, for that matter. And now I’m actually going to shut up about this, because if I don’t, I’m going to get on some tangent about I Saw the TV Glow (2024), The Substance (2024), Longlegs (2024), and a bunch of other bullshit that I dislike for similar reasons. Whatever, onto the show.
My coming was motivated by a low ticket price and a genuine curiosity, the hope to perhaps give peace a chance. In the end, the show only served to confirm my preexisting notions about the band; as expected, any poignancy or mystique surrounding the whole “edgy lost media vibe” that Panchiko tries to sell was completely absent from their performance. Few interesting sounds or interpretations of the music’s unique elements, even those pre-existing within the tracks, were to be found. Certain moments, like the sample in D>E>A>T>H>M>E>T>A>L or the gaps of electronic whirring in CUT, both of which legitimately interesting ideas, felt rushed or skimmed entirely. I was disappointed with the lack of inspiration and grace behind the individual performances of songs, but mainly, I was upset with how the band carried themselves.
There was no attempt to take any of it seriously on Panchiko’s part, and that was pretty much established from the get-go. Members repeatedly joked about their old age in a way that was more exemplary of lacking confidence than it was being playful— if people were laughing or bantering back at them, it was more than likely due to the frontman’s squeaky British accent. The stage presence could ultimately be summarized as “lame”.
The audience was mostly kids, which is obviously fine, but it kept reminding me of seeing Alex G in 2022 and sensing a general confusion as to how a concert is supposed to work within the crowd. The kids next to me kept anxiously and audibly checking a Spotify playlist of the “Panchiko 2024 Setlist” as they waited for D>E>A>T>H>M>E>T>A>L to finally play. It felt like the crowd intuitively knew this performance was lame and whack, and that while they were just going to stand there as the music lulled, they’d still post an Instagram story of it later. It goes without saying that nobody was really dancing or singing all that much, which is maybe a product of the groomer-type dynamic between Panchiko and their fans. Instead, the majority of the crowd’s engagement was shown via recording songs in their entirety.
It was the sort of concert that ended with a shrug and a quiet dissolution.
Also: sorry to Glare, who were the openers. So many people skipped you guys, myself included. It was an accident, I swear.
#11: Joeyy, Laker, and Smokedope2016
Showbox, Sep. 5th 2024
I’ll preface this by saying that when I saw the collective “Shed Theory”—Joeyy, Laker, Dream Caster, Henry Mosto, Ricky Chix, among others—in July of 2023, it may have been transformative. Aside from the number #2 and #1 spots on this list (and maybe also Drain Gang in 2022), I can think of no other concert I’ve been at in which the atmosphere, of both the music and its artist(s), was so fully embodied. Totally submerged in sweat and haze and sleepiness, we the audience were crushed together within the stuffy confines of the venue (Madame Lou’s, which is more of a bar), likewise the performers outnumbered the stage probably twenty to one; I truly cannot stress enough that the characters onstage were innumerable and the concert was endless—like, at least three hours long, at one point featuring a fake-out in which a man vaguely resembling Joeyy came out on stage. Eera played two full DJ sets. I’m not even sure if this was planned.
It was steamy and dreamlike, like being in a jungle or the inside of a humidifier; it was lazy and euphoric, accurately capturing the subject matter (“nodding”, lean, painkillers) of the songs; most palpable, it was uncannily evocative of the specific experience of being stuck at a fucked suburban “house party” where a number of guys you kind of know are low-key trying to record music while being severely hindered by the effects of substances—which, if that’s not the essence of Shed Theory, then I don’t know what is.
But I am, in fact, speaking of a different concert from the one featured on this list. This time around was not the same, which I had established going in (Reiterating, I am well aware that you cannot redo an experience, this is maybe why I placed the emphasis on live music to begin with). Hence, I was quite lacking in any expectation. It would be just Laker and Joeyy, joined by Smokedope2016. And while I felt mostly indifferent towards the main acts, I was actually intrigued by Smokedope2016 and really did not want to miss his set. I missed his set.
I came in halfway through Laker and immediately felt a sinking “out-of-place” feeling as I realized just how much things had shifted since last time. I could not, for the life of me, get a grasp of the irony barrier between the audience and the performer; it wasn’t that I thought the swarm of teenage boys present were miraculously unaware of the Shed Theory concept (the image that Joeyy and Laker have constructed for themselves is explicitly embedded within their music and personal marketing), it’s just that they weirdly seemed to be treating this event no differently than they would a Ken Carson concert, or more accurately, a high school prom where a Ken Carson song is being played.
It had officially been made clear to me that Shed Theory no longer occupied the same cultural space as it did just shy of a year before this concert; the way I see it, their niche turf was quickly overturned by similar gimmick-acts such as Phreshboyswag, who have in turn already been “phased out” by the online cultural-iron that flattens all in its path. There’s never not going to be a certain charm that comes with the small or humble beginnings of an artist, but even putting aside my prior experience, this show just felt a bit off-putting—a sad reminder of weird things like aging and falling off.
Oddly, I’m finding difficulty in expressing this feeling, but I’ll just say that there was a knowingly dreadful mood draped over the whole thing. It was as though I, as well as the performers, somehow possessed the knowledge that this marked the impending end of something finite, and despite our mutual awareness, they would drag it to its slow death anyway. It was like looking into a sick dog’s eyes.
If nothing else, I’ll admit to indulging myself during what can only be described as the “TikTok Rizz Party” level DJ Set that took place in the intermission, which featured “Vanished” by Crystal Castles, some tracks from the recent mediocre Bladee album, “Just Your Doll” by Snow Strippers, “Still into You” by Paramore, and “Love SOSA”, of course. Some great favorites for the kids.
Also, Joeyy performed “I’m Not God, But I Wish I Was” alongside Smokedope2016 and it made for a nice moment. He was smart not to overstay his welcome, performing probably shy of 45 minutes.
I shook Joeyy’s hand before exiting the venue, once again understanding that things probably wouldn’t be this way ever again.
#10: Bktherula
Neumos, June 27th 2024
Only in digging up this image now do I remember the full Yori Sport outfit. Haha.
My justification for attending this show: This is cheap, and Bktherula looks like a nice woman. Both ended up being fairly reasonable assessments. Well—sort of, I paid $20 for two hours of parking in Capitol Hill.
The day began at the Jollibee in Columbia City, where I ate mac and cheese and mashed potatoes in yesterday’s clothes. I drove through pelting rain to browse dry shampoo options at Ulta, and then did so again to arrive at venue Neumos on time for the show. I would be going it alone this time. On the way there, I brushed up on the discography of the artist, since I didn’t really know her all that well.
The opener, Skaiwater, who I had never heard of before this show, left me partially mystified by his presence. (I would eventually realize him to be the guy behind that TikTok audio that goes “Oh my god”. In typing that just now, I recognize that it is meaningless when typed.) He was outright flamboyant—carrying a shoulder bag—but the young guys in the crowd still seemed earnestly invested in him and matched his excitement nonetheless. They called out “Skai!” in a way that lacked fear of being accused homosexual, almost as if to throw up their shoulders like, “I can’t deny it, the man’s got style”.
Bk herself performed briefly, but once again, this was the right call. For the entire show, she stood in front of a screen that continuously looped a deranged animation depicting her as Trollface, with loud Windows XP style pop-ups that read “U MAD??”. This, coupled with her beaming white eye-makeup and honest charisma, made for a captivating arrangement. She was fun and appreciative in a down-to-earth way and probably also way too warm in that sweatsuit—Neumos is a historically sweaty operation. I thought it was sweet that she offered to hang around and take photos with fans for awhile after.
The turnout was notably small, but there was some real joy amongst the clumsy youthfulness of the crowd. I met a couple nice kids, including a girl so ecstatic to be there that she proudly proclaimed Bk “was her ringtone” to at least three people, myself included.
There was a twerk-off on stage at one point, and then they rushed all the girls off promptly; that was weird. What’s important is that things were mostly enjoyable, and that’s always going to be admirable if it stems from an artist that you’re not personally invested in.
For better or for worse, my main takeaway as I walked back to the $20 overnight parking spot alone was a longing for something more, experience or connection or otherwise. My body felt heavy and dizzy, like I had just failed to confess to my crush and was forced to watch the moment pass by with indifference.
#9: JPEGMafia
Showbox SoDo, Aug. 15th 2024
I’m not a huge fan of JPEGMafia’s (I cannot bring myself to refer to him as “Peggy” here) attitude towards his art or his fans. Prior to this concert, he posted an insanely whiny Instagram story threatening to “leave any venue that turned down his speakers”. First this filled me with severe secondhand embarrassment, and then contempt, so much so that I went out of my way to purchase $1 earplugs at the concessions stand; I typically opt to endure noise. Despite how this is beginning to sound, I do like a decent amount of JPEGMafia’s discography, and I was in fact looking forward to this show. But in the spirit of accuracy, that excitement was more due to opening act Jane Remover, who’s music I like probably just a touch more.
I hate to start with something like this—partially because it’s reductive and unhelpful, but mainly because it’s unfunny and is the exact kind of commentary you’d expect to hear from somebody who follows xiu_shoegaze on Instagram and makes self-deprecating jokes about liking Aphex Twin and Death Grips wherein the supposed punchline of this joke is the reference to a name alone—but the crowd at this show was precisely what you would expect: mostly teenage white males who “like rap music” in the hyper-specific manner that entails Kendrick Lamar, MF Doom, Freddie Gibbs, Kanye West, Playboi Carti, JPEGMafia. You best believe they were absolutely fucking up “Not Like Us” when it came on in the intermission.
There’s nothing particularly wrong with this (well, whatever) but it did mean that Jane Remover’s performance ultimately fell on earplugs and stiff bodies. In the moment, I remember being thoroughly disappointed by this reality. My friends and I tried to rally some semblance of action, but it was quite literally futile. Though writing this now, I don’t actually blame anybody there for not “getting hyped enough”; this just comes across as an error, a miscommunication between the performer and the audience. While I can picture a clear overlap between the Jane Remover listener and the JPEGMafia listener no problem, that chunk of the Venn diagram was simply not the one present that night. It just wasn’t happening, for whatever reason. Maybe it happened in LA; it probably worked out good in LA. Maybe RXKNephew was the better pick for the Seattle show, or the better pick overall. Once again, I wouldn’t doubt that the crowd was probably just a touch too primed by the “Ken Carson show” mindset.
When it came time, JPEGMafia’s performance was good. He covered a lot of ground, and to my relief did so with few corny comments. At the expense of his being so comprehensive, individual songs—even big ones like “BALD!”—were sometimes reduced or simplified in order to accommodate the vast setlist. This is an approach I tend to respect, but I think in this case it managed to inflict the feeling of furiously skipping through your Liked Songs on Spotify until the initial desire to enjoy music is gradually burnt away and all you’re left with is exhaustion; the crowd went really, really hard at first, but the energy had noticeably dwindled by the time the Devon Hendryx era cuts were being dished out. For the most part though, the audience assured that they were capable of having a great time if they actually knew the artist on stage (I’m sorry, Jane Remover), so things panned out to be sweaty and aggressive in the way you would hope a JPEGMafia concert would be. Expectations were met, eyebrow piercing was impaired. Successful, if you ask me.
#8: POiSON GiRL FRiEND
The Crocodile, Oct. 21st 2024
The insane setup
Having seen another Japanese band at the exact same venue a month prior to this show, I was able to gather some insight as to how Japanese performers fare in America: for one, they love encores. Expect one, but realistically three, of them. Second, they get extremely sentimental about the whole ordeal. There will be tears, of joy or deep appreciation, the whole thing will be surprisingly saccharine.
I have to be careful not to accidentally overstate that excitement I had for this show, because while this was a big deal to me—a great amount of my early high school memory is set to the soundtrack of MELTING MOMENT (1992) and LOVE ME (1994)—I knew it was going to be an instance of an artist far out of their element. This would be POiSON GiRL FRiEND’s first time in North America, despite the bulk of her discography being over thirty years old. On top of this, Seattle was the first show of the tour. It could be bumpy, awkward, maybe even bad.
Adjusting my expectations accordingly, I took down a plate of sashimi at a nearby restaurant before being dropped off at The Crocodile slightly earlier than I wanted to be. I lingered and observed; the audience that night exuded a visible texture of youth performativity and signaling in appearances, like, you could really tell it was made certain that every canvas or leather bag had an ostensibly “authentic” distribution of silver hardware to Monchichi/Kewpie/Miffy keychains prior to showing up. Since I came alone, I got to partake in some eavesdropping when the guy behind me failed to flirt with one of said Miffy-bag-charm-layered-haircut girls (of the particularly stiff and unreceptive variant, at that). I eventually met some sweet, conversational people, luckily one of whom would turn out to be the only other person with a strong conviction to dance.
The opener was this girl Alex Sloane, who nobody knew, but at some point she played a song that I was sure I had heard from Instagram Reels. Her presence was characterized by a glaringly obvious low self-esteem: smooth dark hair swept back in a perfect ribbon, she delivered psuedo-PinkPanthress music that featured lyrics of daydreaming and longing, as well as the occasional meek “My name is Alex” or remark about how fortunate she was to have been invited along for the tour. She reminded me, in a tragic way, of those dutiful girls in high school who did dance team and ate KIND bars and feigned a childish level of disgust when the conversation turned to crushes or sex. At certain points, I think I got a bit too transfixed by her ballerina or doll-like beauty and had to shun myself out of being a weirdo. All this aside, I was actually enjoying the “girly” schtick she had going, well that is before she wordlessly clicked on her MacBook and scampered offstage.
The main attraction was somehow even more emotionally disorienting. Accompanied by just one guitarist and a projector that depicted black and white footage of her aimlessly roaming the streets of Japan, POiSON GiRL FRiEND spent much of the concert propped up on a stool, reading the lyrics to every song off an iPad placed on a music stand before her. She was a bit older, and more serious, than I expected. At one point, she pulled her phone out of what appeared to be a plastic Jack-O-Lantern bin used for Trick or Treating; she then attempted to play a file containing pre-recorded maraca sounds for a track, but eventually gave up because the audio would pause whenever the screen turned itself off.
In this sense, everything she did carried with it melancholy, from her crumbling vocals to the way she stared off at nothing in between songs. At first, I felt a very real concern that she was near tears—and rest assured she definitely did end up crying—or that the concert would potentially end on an premature, depressing note, like when you see a clip of a classic rock band performing on their “final tour” and the only thing you can think is just how painful it must be for them (physically or spiritually). However, after a couple songs passed and some of the kinks were straightened out, I started to consider that this was possibly very intentional—a part of the act, a way of embodying the heartbreak and devotion that lies at the core of POiSON GiRL FRiEND’s songs. Once convinced of this, I watched with intrigue as she would give a quick “thank you” to the crowd before darkening her facial expression at the cue of the next song.
A couple of times, she got up and danced in a particular demeanor of stiff arm-swinging motions, which was endearing to myself and everyone. Of the crowd, me and the nice girl I had met earlier were of few to reciprocate, which was admittedly not surprising in the slightest. By then I had long gathered that a demographic like this is quick to “exciting” forms of engaging with live music— “moshing” whenever possible, the “Ken Carson effect”—but bewildered by something like dancing. Interestingly enough, this closely resembled the environment during the Jane Remover set: an audience more “polite”, almost patronizingly so, than they are involved. There was cheering and woo-ing and plenty of “We love you!” throughout, but not much display of affection in the most obvious forms of swaying or singing (most songs were in English—but in all fairness there was a good amount of Japanese and French present, so it’s no surprise that nobody was bursting into chorus there).
I wonder if this pattern amongst crowds comprised mainly of musically “aware” or “sensible” Gen Z—who often acquire their initial music knowledge, or at the very least the bulk of their exposure to music and therefore live music culture, through social media—could be a result of amplified youth self-consciousness within a surveilled culture, particularly when in the context of such a competitive social realm of “being into music”. They see so many videos mocking “TikTok fans” or “Gen Z concertgoers”: for yelling inappropriately (famous at Mitski concerts) or singing too loudly, or for that matter singing too quietly, effectively outing themselves as “fake” or “new” fans. As a result, they’ve grown petrified by the idea of appearing inauthentic or, realistically, uncool. Ironically, this leads them to second-guess and censor entirely normal concert behaviors, like singing and dancing to the fucking music.
The show definitely went on too long—three encores—and two people fainted. No, I don’t know how or why that happened. When the concert ended, the girl I spent the whole time dancing with turned to me and said something like, “Well, that was interesting”, to which I couldn’t agree more. It was interesting, and that was maybe precisely what it should have been.
The two of us walked back in the same direction. We discussed her vast travel experience, as well as what we were planning to be for Halloween: she, Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin, and me, Layla from Buffalo 66.
#7: Mass of the Fermenting Dregs (マスドレ)
The Crocodile, Sep. 25th 2024
This would be the “other” Japanese concert referenced above, where I first learned about sappiness and excessive encores.
I brought my metalhead brother along with me, and together we bobbed in the sea of White and Asian and Wasian nerds that were in attendance. They varied in specific niche or age group of nerd, to be precise, but you could tell that mostly they were knowledgable in guitar pedals or Japanese rock bands or specific genre-labeling like “post-hardcore shoegaze”; that they likely held favorable opinions of Neon Genesis Evangelion (1995), Perfect Blue (1997), Cowboy Bebop (1998), and still thought that Serial Experiments Lain (1998) and FLCL (2000) were novel things to bring up in the anime discussion. When “Never as Tired as When I’m Waking Up” by LCD Soundsystem played over the speaker in between sets, the guy next to me took the pleasure to explain to the girl he brought how important the song was—he’s right, that song rocks.
My brother and I are White Nerds to be sure, but neither of us fits this particular mold. I think it instills some level of relief in me though, to be amongst a crowd in which I feel little personal connection to their niche: “Nah, I don’t really care about distortion pedals or whatever. This band is cool, though.” It would be good to carry a similar attitude irrespective of setting.
I thoroughly enjoyed the first opener, Blush, who were a Singaporean shoegaze band. They were cute—legitimately, I just thought they were cute, that was all. The band also seemed to perfectly fit the bill of this crowd’s interests: endearing female vocalist and a whole lot of guitar fuzz (Wow, groundbreaking). The next performer was Cam Kahin, a solo act who would be unfortunately completely soiled by his distracting guitarist, a grown man in a Thrasher hoodie and cut off Dickies with a carabiner on the belt loop. The guitarist repeatedly bounded across the stage, stuck his tongue out, shook his head around; he leapt into the air and slammed down on his strings at the slightest implication of any “big moment” in a song. He greatly disturbed my brother and I, and I’m willing to argue the bassist onstage, too. If I remember correctly, Cam Kahin’s music wasn’t even really bad, just surprisingly generic given the circumstances.
Mass of the Fermenting Dregs (Mass) came out to a dramatic and extended ovation; I remember imagining that they might not play any songs and would instead just chill there while we cheered, and I was oddly accepting of this. So much cheering. The nerds were absolutely thrilled to be there, repeatedly yelling out nice phrases in Japanese—who knew so many White people spoke passable Japanese?2 —to the performers, who seemed genuinely shocked and moved by the amount of love they were receiving. There was a lot of charming language-barrier-back-and-forth between the stage and the audience, which was honestly just as integral to the performance as the music (and certainly stronger in my memory).
On that note, Mass impressively stood the test of time in terms of both energy and technical ability; they sounded really good. The vocalist powered through her screams to the best of her ability, beating her chest and vowing “ganbarimasu” when needed. I don’t know how they still managed to have the stamina to play some of those winding instrumental tracks that bordered on “math rock” and reached upwards of seven minutes, because I barely had the focus to endure them—so, props for that.
The crowd was shy, but at some point it happened: some kids decided that headbanging and thrashing in place was not enough, and we had to actually move around to the music. It ended up striking a good balance wherein the uncomfortable Japanese music nerds formed a neat, judgmental wall to separate themselves from the antsy Japanese music nerds who wanted to shove each other. I have reason to believe that Mass was potentially not expecting this type of action to occur—likely due to a lack of experience in America—because despite the insane level of relationship-forming throughout the concert, they never really acknowledged the people in the “pit”, which I thought was funny.
It feels pointless to say, as I’m sure you probably know by now, but the concert was extremely drawn out and absurdly tender, ending with multiple encores and a selfie with the audience.
#6: Sky Ferreira
Neptune Theater, Sep. 24th 2024
Neptune Theater bias—a severely underrated venue. There was truly no better choice for a Sky Ferreira show in Seattle. The place is old and stuffy and perpetually illuminated in royal blue, which is a disturbingly accurate manifestation of the future-young-adult-alternative-indie-rock-concert-escapade daydreams I would conjure up as a preteen when listening to something such as Mac DeMarco: moody, atmospheric, serious. While shockingly small, Ferreira’s discography oozes visceral associations like these, of dated juvenile memory or fantasy, even more so, of the specific cultural moment they’re derived from. I mean by now, the mythicizing of “2010s”— specifically “2010s alternative”—is nearing the proportions that the 80s or 90s nostalgia had not too long ago (which one has to imagine was the biggest factor behind her ability to tour in 2024). Essentially, Ferreira is a lot more suggestive of a surrounding “vibe” than she is of her actual music. I can wholly sympathize with those who might’ve gone into this concert hinging on it to fulfill fond memories and internet-induced maladaptive daydreams alike, because I think to a certain degree, that idea was baked into the tour.
I intentionally did not show up on time, because Sky Ferreira was going to do the same, and I was not going to let her best me at something I quite excel at. Ultimately, she would win and I would end up standing around in my own perspiration during the remnants of a new-wave inspired DJ set (which honestly deserved more acknowledgement from the crowd, it had potential to be fun). I was surrounded by girls, truly just girls, and maybe a handful of gay Millennial or older Gen Z males. Most girls were there with one to three friends, and remained in these bubbles; it was not a social environment, in fact it was maybe even hostile. As a noteworthy example, two Hater Ass Girls behind me spent much of the concert exchanging eye-rolls and passive aggressive comments regarding a neighboring trio of Drunk Girls who were apparently singing and screaming and moving around too much at a live music event. This culminated when at some point during the main act, one of the Hater Ass Girls finally used her words to inform the Drunk Girls that they were screaming too loud, or maybe moving too hard, I don’t know which was more offensive in their eyes—God, get over yourselves.
I think those unfamiliar with Ferreira’s habits were growing frustrated or restless sitting through her playlist of Aphex Twin and Gang Gang Dance and Radiohead’s “Kid A” for more than an hour past the start time posted on their tickets. Eventually, she did show up, along with a band of three incredibly normal looking dudes, and they opened with “Boys”, a solid pick. Even though I claim to not care about an artist’s live sound, I can’t deny that her voice was stunning with vigor, demanding my attention throughout.
Ferreira was awkward in a manner that was both demonstrative of all the aforementioned pubescent swag of the time, and also clearly born from an unfiltered authenticity. She came out looking exactly as I had expected, dressed no differently than what a Google Images search for “Sky Ferreira” might yield. Her demeanor was stiff, almost hasty, and for the longest time she didn’t so much as crack a smile (she appeared to progressively warm up, though). Mostly, she just walked back and forth from one end of the stage to the other, stopping at each side for a verse a time, always ending back in the center—this pattern would repeat for every single song performed that night.
She compulsively flipped her hair. She obsessively fiddled with her ear piece. She took long pauses in between tracks to glare at her band, fiddle with her ear piece, adjust the heavy layers of her outfit, say a breathy “sorry” or “thank you”, and then flip her hair.
She was drenched in stage light, which, due to her signature uniform of a t shirt, heavy flannel, leather jacket, black jeans, and combat boots, led her to at one point disappear backstage for an unknown amount of time to recollect—or, that’s probably not what actually happened, but it’s what I’ll tell myself in order to remain hopeful for her future. Meanwhile, the band members gradually moved from expressions of confusion to aggravation and then to concern, until consequently one of them followed after and was able to retrieve her. Luckily, since she did not once remove her dark aviators for the entirety of the show, she was likely not otherwise afflicted by the display.
Not too long after this incident took place, Ferreira would announce that she was ending the show early, citing “sickness” as her reason. She skipped just a few songs, none of which I really missed, instead jumping straight to “Everything is Embarrassing”, which at last succeeded in defrosting the crowd.
I won’t pretend to have a profound personal connection to the era or anything—the only time I ever experienced Tumblr during the alternative zeitgeist was to tour its self-harm and anorexia content, because Onision’s videos targeting mentally ill young girls inspired within my adolescent-self a morbid curiosity. But if you went into this concert expecting anything other than a late start, interruptions, little acknowledgement of the audience, and a premature ending, then even I reserve the right to question your credibility on this matter. As a Sky Ferreira concert, this checked every box it had to. The feeling of her music and character were captured to great effect: the self-indulgent youthful dream and the necessary disappointment that comes along with it.
#5: Oneohtrix Point Never
Neptune Theater, Apr. 17th 2024
I’m making the executive decision to not open with what ended up being almost the exact same tangent regarding Neptune Theater and “edgy internet subcultures”, but you can use your imagination: imagine it’s all submerged in color and spacey again. Yep. Old theater, new synth sounds. Here’s the part where I say some bullshit like “it’s basically an Eccojam if it were a physical space”, but if I were writing that it would probably be a little more flowery and with weirder punctuation. Great, now we’re all on the same page, I’m sure.
(I guess I just really like it there. Maybe I’ll have to go see George Clanton later this year after all.)
I went to this show with three people who probably—absolutely—all love Oneohtrix Point Never (OPN) more than me. It was a brisk spring day when we walked to the theater, observing dead pigeons and abandoned Lime Scooters along the way; I attempted to perform a cover of OPN’s “Child Soldier” several times before we arrived. Upon entry, we were greeted with the sound of electronic ambience reverberating and a peek of purple light spilling out from the floor’s entry. I impatiently waited for one of my friends to finish stashing his knife somewhere outside in order to get past the entry, now partially convinced that we were somehow now missing OPN’s performance in entirety.
When I did weave my way in, I was relieved to find that it was not OPN on stage, but rather a delicate young Indian woman who stood before an archaic behemoth of buttons and switches. She was operating this machinery with a focus intense enough to justify her not facing the audience, but somehow still effortless in appearance—like I had just stumbled upon some deity singing to herself at a hidden waterfall. The lights enveloping the room shifted colors with the rise and fall of her tracks, which to be fair here, is really all her tracks did (the music itself did not particularly interest me). I had no clue who this woman was during the performance, but I later found out her name was Arushi Jain or Modular Princess, one of the two. She was a good choice for an OPN opener, nerdy enough to satisfy the modular synth-obsessed and gear-head crowd—she even did some live voice modulating—and stimulating enough to entertain us regular people.
OPN arrived to an exceedingly warm welcome from the array of fans, whom a bizarre amount of bore a serious uncanny resemblance to him. (Not kidding, that was one of my main takeaways from the show: “Why does everybody here lowkey look like OPN?”) He was joined by a couple of innocuous-looking dudes who controlled a miniature doll-replica of him, as well as the stage, and projected footage of it onto a screen behind him; I have no clue as to what the inspiration or story behind this was. Generally speaking, I thought the screen visuals were a bit questionable or disjointed—I can’t really remember any exact ones other than a series of distorted cartoon clips, one of them containing Tinker Bell—but the lighting and excessive fog machine use made up for it in terms of atmospheric quality.
While largely drawing from his recent album, “Again”, OPN managed to perform a respectably varied setlist, which is an impressive feat for someone with such a broad spread of a career. Unlike Justice, the special live remixes felt tasteful and rewarding—it was this concert, not Justice, that managed to succeed in wow-ing me with its reinventions of moments from an original discography. In the way a gleaming-Redditor-fanboy might excitedly perk up at a “reference”, I shared mutual joy with the crowd when OPN closed with a special track that reused the famous Kleenex commercial sample from “Sleep Dealer”.
With that in mind, this was probably one of the most earnest displays of appreciation between artist and fan that I have ever seen. Everybody seemed magnetized, either staring in awe or closing their eyes and leaning their head back to really feel each song. I couldn’t help but steal glances at the guy in the dead-center who was sobbing uncontrollably during the latter half of the set, or the kid to my left who wore clunky ear-protection headphones and would react by bouncing up and down or flapping his arms or snapping his fingers, just two of many that night who were admirably honest about how the music affected them. Even though this is probably not the sort of music nor fanbase that would entail high-energy movement or extreme reactions, there was an encompassing and reciprocal positivity throughout. Do you dance to this kind of music? I wasn’t sure, but I tried.
At some point near the end, OPN—who, in this context, I now oddly feel inclined to refer to as “Daniel”, as though he were my friend—expressed his gratitude for this enthusiasm, letting us know that his performance at Coachella just a few days prior hadn’t gone over nearly as well (Shocker). He played several extra tracks, checking first with the audience to see if we wanted an “evil” or “happy” ending, then took videos of the crowd to put on his Instagram story before exiting. I got the impression that he truly was not expecting a favorable experience, and I admit I was equally as surprised. Leading up to the show I was somewhat ambivalent; despite a love of OPN, I worried that the music wouldn’t translate to its best ability in a live setting, and I’d be left with a soured image of what was once cool and evocative to me (Not going to beat a dead horse here). Good thing the exact opposite occurred! Yay!
#4: Ariel Pink
El Corazon, Mar. 9th 2024
For some reason, I really wanted to go to this show; as in, I was practically begging my friends to come with me, repeatedly checking to see if they had purchased their $30 advance ticket to an event that had zero chance of selling out whatsoever. It’s not like I’m an Ariel Pink super-fan (if such thing exists) or something, so I truly don’t know what compelled me to place so much faith into this middle aged man’s performance at a tiny bar. But ultimately, I was right to do so.
And sure, I’ll preface by saying: Yes, I know. I know. I am aware of where off-color-singer-songwriter Ariel Pink was located on January 6th, 2021. But he didn’t actually like, go in there, okay? I’m fairly certain he might not have even been there for that part. It’s not like he’s up for a pardon or some shit.
That’s all you’ll get from me on that matter, at least for now. I don’t feel like typing about any of the other stuff either, beating a dead horse and whatnot. So: Yes, I know.
Since this was a classic “El Corazon stop on a small artist’s tour”, which entails cramming an unwarranted amount of bands onto a single bill for the night, my friends and I knew to arrive late with the goal of skipping as many openers as possible. This of course meant treating the ginormous REI store next door as a personal playground of sorts while we waited. After enough 16 person tents were browsed and sci-fi reminiscent packets of sweetened “energy gels” were consumed, we headed over to face off with the bar’s security, who are always sure to play up a hardened “no-nonsense” attitude.
Unfortunately, we succeeded in missing all but one opener, the noise group “Period Bomb”, whose absurd output of brashness and freakiness—wailing, moaning vocals; screechy guitar feedback, erratic gyrating—aroused little interest within myself and everybody else there. I was originally going to write some snarky statement about noise music, but it would just be wrong to insinuate the non-tonal or abrasive quality was the reason their performance sucked. I take no issue with either of those things whatsoever. I do, however, take issue with corniness and acting whack. I am therefore haunted by the vocalist’s addressing of a fellow bandmate with something to the effect of, “We got Rat Bastard here! [met with underwhelming applause] Do you guys seriously not know Rat Bastard? Fucking legend in the Noise scene!” This was followed up by more “scene” commentary, delivered in that sanctimonious tone, as if the audience was simply too uneducated or ignorant to appreciate what was shrieking and writhing in front of them. Yea, great way to attract more people to your already unwelcoming music.
For most of the time leading up to his set, Ariel was just standing around by his merch stand, dressed in a frumpy Carhartt jumpsuit, with an unlit cigarette hanging out of his mouth, which remained there for at least 25 minutes. My boyfriend tried to briefly inquire him about the soundtrack for the Safdie brothers’ film “Heaven Knows What”, and Ariel simply replied that he forgot he had made it. His posture elicited a Jim Carrey “Grinch” brand of cartoonish brooding and solitary demeanor; he had permanently glassy eyes, and probably the most soft-spoken voice I have ever heard. He’s also definitely telling the truth in “Mature Themes” when he says he’s 5’4.
And it was a great performance. The sound was polished yet still living and breathing, and I couldn’t contain my smile, couldn’t stop myself from dancing. His bandmates wore kitschy costumes, such as white briefs paired with a vampire cape, that played into the selectively referential “Haunted Graffiti” aesthetic of Ariel’s most iconic period. Ariel was himself on stage: he first threw under-his-breath remarks, then very outward and mic’d jabs, at his drummer, for playing fills when he apparently wasn’t supposed to; he introduced one of his songs with “this is a song from when I was transgender”; there was at least one moment in the beginning where I thought he was going to walk off stage because he was getting so frustrated with the sound guy. He closed with a series of audience requests, which were shouted with enough enthusiasm to confirm that I was far from alone in not wanting the show to be over. Highlights of the performance included “Round and Round” and, to bring it up again because I love it, “Mature Themes”.
Oh yeah—I should say, literally none of this important, because the real event took place after the show had ended.
Two of my friends wanted to try and give Ariel a copy of their CDs, and maybe even talk with him a bit, so we waited outside until we caught him solemnly smoking a cigarette by the backdoor. We approached, he accepted the gift, and though appearing guarded or shy, he was open to chatting with us. At one point, my friend asked Ariel something along the lines of if he had “seen anything good lately”, or “what he had been into”, and that’s where it started to unravel a bit, because he bluntly responded with “Honestly, nothing”. He insisted that he was a family man now, that the music and art worlds had severed ties with him; he then told us he was blacklisted by Live Nation, meaning he could not get booked by most venues (going so far as to say that he was essentially “banned” from New York and LA). For the next forty five minutes or so, Ariel painted to us a winding and ensnaring picture of Cancel Culture, the Radical Left, the Music Industry, the Democrats, and so forth, all murderous “psychopaths” that contributed to his disenfranchisement. I kept having to turn my ear towards him because he spoke in near-whisper. At one point, some kid came up and tried to get him to sign a vape and Ariel, mistaking it for a recording device, flinched and told him that he didn’t want any of this stuff to get out online. Eventually I had to leave, but my two friends remained there for an additional hour of his rant.
I don’t know how much of this conversation I can tangibly or accurately record, and this in part due to it having been so circular and seemingly endless that I struggled to keep up even as it was ongoing. But in all honesty, my main hangup is that I genuinely felt a lot of intrigue and empathy towards his situation, so I don’t want to misrepresent or twist his words or tone—I fear I’ve already perpetrated this just by virtue of attempting to broadly categorize the subject matter. Frankly, I was humbled when Ariel defeatedly revealed to us that he was, in fact, paying El Corazon to perform there. Due to his status and difficulties securing venues, he would make no money from this “tour” whatsoever.
I walked away with plenty to think about—plenty more conflicted feelings—and undoubtedly, a greater space occupied by Ariel in my mind, and his music, in my life.
As I recollected my encounter with him, it fully clicked with me that the two people most analogous to Ariel, in terms of their story arc and role as a supposed “dissident” of the art world, would be Steven Morrissey and (arguably even more so) Vincent Gallo. Maybe this is where we discover the formula for being a great artist: be outwardly offensive and antisocial—but actually awkward and soft-spoken with a good work ethic—, make highly confessional and challenging art, get “canceled” at some point either due to said art or your inability to coexist with others while working on it, and then nosedive into being even more socially inept and provocative than before. In no way am I joking, this yields ideal results.
#3: Charli XCX
Climate Pledge Arena, Oct. 23 2024
I almost didn’t go to this—sort of. At 7:00 PM on October 23rd, I was still at home reading on the couch, no sign of a Charli XCX ticket in my possession, but I knew wasn’t not going to go. For whatever reason, I had some completely unfounded and assured sense that I would end up at this concert. I casually rotated and refreshed the webpages of various ticket-purchasing services as I sipped tea and ate dinner.
Then, after stalking the price trackers and securing what I wholeheartedly believe to have been the best possible outcome, I went for it: 30 minutes and $285 later, I was hustling down the wide walkways of Climate Pledge Arena alongside my dear friend3; 10 minutes after that, we were partying to the latter half of shygirl’s set, shoes slick with White Claw that had been spilled nearby.
I can still feel the initial stun upon finding our seats—we instantly turned to each other and exclaimed in unison, “We’re so close!” Normally I’d be kind of a stickler for floor seats, but I maintain that the section next to the stage was the best arrangement, given the price and extremely last minute nature of the decision. (I swear I am not coping.)
Stadium shows are always a trip to me. They constitute a separate category in my mind, out of respect for sheer scale. In a case like this, I can’t make so many comments regarding “crowd energy” or “social environment” or even physical sensations as I would a normal show, because there’s literally too many people. You can really only go off of the small section you’re apart of, or “the whole” as you perceive it from said small section. When I saw The Cure at Climate Pledge in 2023, I left a bit soured because I was trapped amongst seated geriatrics (Gen X), but the level of enthusiasm was visibly different even just a section away. In the case of this being the “Sweat” tour, I thought that the response looked reasonable. But realistically, I spent far too much money to focus on anything other than the spectacle.
Unsurprisingly, much of my time was spent in awe at how seamlessly “brat” was lubed into every corner of the production. It was all outrageous, over-the-top—there was no way to keep track of the amount of wardrobe changing or grinding that took place onstage, or even just, times my eyes widened in response to something Troye Sivan did with/to his entourage of half-naked male backup dancers who looked like they were scouted from the aisles of the Venice Beach Erewhon4. Perhaps most encompassing was the format of the show itself; rather than perform in sets, Charli and Troye alternated every few songs, which created a revolving door into their non-stop Boiler Room set. Really, I think the ingenuity of this lies in the fact that it was attention-span proof: perfectly in line with the pleasure-seeking values and hyperdrive culture surrounding the album, it was all the best parts of scrolling TikTok (constant stimulation and dopamine cycling) with none of the guilt or loss, maybe only some of the eyestrain.
This strong stylistic identity, coupled with the fact that it was the final show in one of the most ubiquitous tours of recent memory (and I say this affectionately, as opposed to some of the others), meant there was pretty much no room for audience burnout; I didn’t even notice there were technically three encores, I was that into it. In spite of the utter excess present, no set-lists were dragged out, no one overstayed their welcome, and overall, I was left wanting more when it ended. I immediately wanted another to experience another “Sweat Tour”.
It’s funny—this concert was so colossal, that there’s actually very little to speak of its specifics. I have written literally nothing about Charli’s charisma as a performer, and I think that’s because likely everyone has been exposed to it by now. As you can probably imagine, it was better in person. As for Troye Sivan, I didn’t (and still don’t) know much about him, but he made short work of winning me over. I felt like he was a children’s cartoon caricature of a “cute boy pop star that is fawned over by the girl characters in an episode”, as though I were obligated to scream “OMG! It’s Troye!” and slap my hands to my face whenever he stepped onstage.
I had a great time with my friend. We did indulge a bond-solidifying moment during “Girl, so confusing” just as many young women likely have by now, and it was beautiful and powerful and normal and we got two Taco Bell Black Bean Crunchwrap Supremes and ate them in my Kia Soul afterwards.
I thought the gay Millennial couple in front of us seemed a bit less thrilled than they should be, but when it got down to “Track #10”, they passionately made out for its entirety—during which, one of them was recording, either the captivating performance or the make out session, or perhaps alternating between the two. Love wins!
#2: Snow Strippers
Neumos, Oct. 22nd 2024
I said I was excited for the Ariel Pink show or whatever, but that pales in comparison to my excitement here. I was so determined to see Snow Strippers that, during their Spring tour, I had formed a vague and convoluted plan to see them perform alongside Elusin in Portland; it would require that I either drive 4 hours or take a train, which is sort of hard to justify for an artist that I’m not exactly emotionally indebted to. Regardless, it didn’t matter because I accidentally bought a 21+ ticket.
(Okay. That makes me sound stupid. I am Not Stupid, and it was Not My Fault. The venue’s website listed their show as an All Ages Event, but the only ticket available at the drop was 21+. Later on, there were tickets that said “all ages” made available—but why weren’t they there at release? I emailed the venue and pleaded with its owner, but it was no use. I had every reason to assume that this was just a formatting error or something. Being young is tragic, right?)
I was bummed about this, not necessarily due to a personal obsession with the artist, but because it truly felt like it was the time to be at a Snow Strippers show. Much like with the “Sweat Tour”, the increased attention on their live shows was inescapable. And while I had been a follower of the duo for awhile, the cultural property that they acquired in 2024 seemed special and ephemeral to me. I felt I couldn’t miss this precise fleeting moment, like it would be gone in a flash and later rubbed in my face by the next generation of teens in some form of false-nostalgia-longing social media post.
“Ugh, why did I have to be 11 in 2024 instead of being at a prime Snow Strippers show?”
Fortunately for me, it wouldn’t pass me by: they toured again in the Fall. In October, I returned to the humid shoebox that is Neumos in Capitol Hill. One of the openers—Damon Rush or damon r.—canceled, and I missed most of the other—Suzy Sheer—because I was busy getting a banh mi sandwich with my boyfriend. Though unreasonably distressed by both of these facts, it ended up working out perfect; I saw the exact amount that I needed to.
Suzy Sheer was a guy, to the surprise of many it seemed, and a very succinct one at that. His set was probably thirty minutes max (I’m estimating, because I heard it start while I was in line), but he drew a high energy from the crowd within that short time frame. I could feel it upon entry, considering the time between me rounding the corner and first catching sight of him, and me being engulfed by the conglomerate of people, was only a mere minute or so.
Miraculously—and this is an underrated positive at any concert—this high was maintained due to the short wait time in between sets. Within fifteen minutes, of which I was incredibly antsy, Tati and Graham came out bouncing to the familiar pounding piano sample of “Just Your Doll”. In an instant, my nervous system was returned to the exact physical sensations of seeing Death Grips a few years back, as I got swept into a mass of bodies that behaved much like quicksand or sludge, suddenly glued to my camo-laden peers and squirming in place. The audience remained in this stasis, gnashing against each other for awhile, but eventually would give and allow for more (albeit squished) movement. It goes without saying that I was ecstatic.
As if attending their own concert, the duo exuded pure excitement from start to finish, jumping nonstop, sometimes pulling fans up to join them. Tati was unsurprisingly the highlight: white mini-skirt that appeared to be made of polyester or some other stretchy athletic material, dark suede boots with tassels all over, a youth boys’ size T-shirt that read “BEACH MODE: ON”—a truly great outfit. She whipped around the stage, dancing in her signature style of choppy-yet-natural, igniting the crowd, soaking in the constant and insurmountable beams of phone flashes. I’m not quite sure what Graham was doing the whole time—if he was doing anything, because more often than not he abandoned his post at the MacBook to dance with Tati—but every song was littered with interruptions like “We love prescription drugs”, “Night Killaz”, and the obligatory barrage of gun-cocking and air-horn sound effects.
I could barely discern any “live vocals” over the sheer auditory assault in the room, but isn’t an emphasis on the amateur or trashy a key part of Snow Strippers’ image? (Check out the YouTube comments under their Boiler Room set, and you’ll find this is a divisive topic.) It’s suggestive of college parties over spring break where the “DJ” is actually just a Spotify user who happens to own a $130 deck, so the whole time he’s just doing really long cross-fades and occasionally throwing in sounds. The product of a lack of care or technical ability, or a deliberate creative decision (probably a bit of both), it communicates their sensibilities and message the same—so I support.
In keeping with the griminess5, the audience was slick with sweat after less than one song: I was fully wedged between other sticky young people, my bra strap came undone at some point, and I was both losing hairs of my own and amassing the strands of others, plucking them via the moisture on my arm. Youth and relevance were at the center of the night, a sentiment that was once again reaffirmed by a short but thorough set. It was, without a shadow of doubt, the most visceral and carnal fun I have had at a concert in a long time.
I don’t know what the future holds for Snow Strippers—if I’ll feel something close to what I do about analogous cultural flashes, like Joeyy—but I’m truly glad I was able to experience them in this moment.
#1: Mk.gee
Showbox SoDo, Sep. 3 2024
Perhaps my 2026 New Year’s Resolution will be to stop “glazing” this guy. But that time is not now.
My favorite concert of 2024 was, above all else, a pleasant surprise. Mainly because this artist is new to me, and not at all someone I would’ve foreseen myself taking any interest in. In fact, when my boyfriend first showed me “Two Star and the Dream Police”, I was genuinely confused as to what this guy’s deal was. I could not, for the life of me, determine whether or not he was one of those many forgettable indie guitar figures that emerged in the late 2010s and landed one semi-successful TikTok hit before fading away out of mediocrity. If you look at his record prior to last year, that’s certainly what he gives off: sort of sensitive and formless and beachy, no real identity outside of being “indie”. I mean, even the previous album title, “A Museum of Contradiction”, makes me roll my eyes.
Somehow, “Two Star and the Dream Police” is actually astonishing and could not exist further from the landfill of superficial indie. It will maybe change “pop” music. I’m embarrassed just writing that. Point is, I do not know how he achieved this total reinvention. It probably took a lot of time and effort. Possibly even a miracle.
I was still quite stumped by Mk.gee when the concert rolled around. So while I had no idea what to expect in actuality, I gathered a few hunches: the first was that my boyfriend and I would be among the youngest there (true). The second was that I would likely be underwhelmed by the live renditions of the tracks due to the vivid and specific qualities they possess (false). The third was that Mk.gee would not have any swag (unfortunately false).
The opener was a DJ who, at times, was exhibiting some cool stuff, though I may have been the only one thinking this, because he was met with a pretty tough crowd. The audience response suggested his set was more of a prolonged obstacle in the way of seeing Mk.gee, which, considering he was mentioned nowhere on the tickets or venue signage and just sort of showed up and immediately got down to it, was perhaps warranted. There was a good amount of confused or embarrassed laughter throughout, but it didn’t feel malicious. For whatever reason, my lasting impression was that this guy was “sort of onto something”—I cannot verify this in any way—and also that he managed to give off the exact feeling of how DJs were depicted in 2000s children’s web browser games, namely Club Penguin.
Shortly after, Mk.gee would arrive onstage almost entirely obscured by a shroud of white mist. For the most part he remained in this state, a silhouette of himself, against the morphing backdrop of deep reds and blues, and flashes of light throughout.
I have to just get it out of the way: he was totally sick. I think part of me still doesn’t want to believe that the person behind “A Museum of Contradictions” could suddenly now sway me with his energy (or maybe I’m just flustered), but fuck it—he had me good. My eyes were completely fixed on that stage. He had the forthright disposition so few performers can properly execute, a “no-nonsense-play-the-music” dutifulness that comes across as naturally developed rather than postured. He was evidently serious about his craft, but not afraid to throw a deafening “Yea!” at the audience when excited, or end the set with a cover of Celine Dion’s “My Heart Will Go On” that featured some screeching eagle sounds. At some point, he was nice enough to take off his hat, which meant we could sort of see him.
More importantly, the best, most compelling aspects of “Two Star and the Dream Police” were at the performance’s core, each individual track done justice through careful renditions that exemplified their interesting qualities. The sounds that define the album—the resonant piano chords, nostalgic synth melodies, and iconic guitar distortion—felt present and palpable, as if every thunder of the guitar clipping was happening inside my bones. Certain musical interludes were extended, notably whenever it was that he switched from the guitar to the puddle of wire and pedal and synthesizer in the middle, but none of the live interpretations felt overkill or unnecessary, instead pulling the audience closer into their atmosphere.
Needless to say, he sounded great: voice, guitar tone, all of it. I don’t see any reason to expand on that.
Ultimately, I’d describe the crowd as “stunned”—there wasn’t much physical activity, at least where I was located. I’m sure you know that normally this would have me miffed, but this time I understood; I was thoroughly captivated. I perceived an air of amazement, occasionally present in glimpses of someone else’s joyfully fixated expression. With some of the big hits, like “Are You Looking Up” or “Candy”, a fair amount of dancing and laughter ensued. The audience struggled to sing along to the chorus’ meter during “Alesis”, which validated my personal difficulties in discerning Mk.gee’s lyrics and matching his vocals in the car. “I Want” stood out as my favorite performance of the night.
Just saying, I still dance, even when mystified. Just something to keep in mind. A mild swing never hurts.
On the walk to the train station, I raved about the sounds, the lights, the smoke, the resounding character of it all. On the train ride home, I texted my old piano teacher to tell him that he simply had to give this album a listen. At work the next day, I pushed Mk.gee onto all the old, classic-rock-loving regulars at the bar top, promising them that he was “doing very cool things with guitar”.
I’m still reeling from it; I was listening to that damn album again yesterday. I don’t think I’ve ever talked about a performance so much after the fact, so that alone should guarantee the number one slot.
As is the case with any other experience, most concerts just come and go, so anything that lasts—the thrilling and the egregious—is well worth the trouble of standing around awkwardly at a million Show Me The Body or Justice shows. It’s just an added bonus when you get something truly special, like this.
Oh yeah, but the guy at the merch stand was a total dick.